From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This article is developed but not approved.
Main Article
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Catalogs [?]
To learn how to update the categories for this article, see here. To update categories, edit the metadata template.
 Definition A country that forms the northernmost part of the United Kingdom; population about 5,200,000. [d] [e]
Checklist and Archives
 Workgroup categories Geography and History [Editors asked to check categories]
 Subgroup category:  Scotland
 Talk Archive none  English language variant Not specified

This article concentrates too much on Scotland from the perspective of a person living in Scotland or at least the UK. To a large extent, it defines Scotland as, "Not England." Too much time is spent defining the relationship between Scotland and England. It needs a change in perspective to make it more informative to a reader from outside the UK and to give Scotland's position with reference to the world, not just the UK. Derek Harkness 11:29, 25 November 2006 (CST)

Etiquette on CZ

We have had within the last few hours substantive changes made in several areas to this article, which in the case of Richard Jensen were described as "cleanup". Removing or changing significant facts is not cleanup, and I ask everyone contributing to this page to discuss their changes and why they have made them.

So far, we have had three completely different mechanisms presented as to how the Scottish Executive is appointed. This is a purely factual matter, and should not be too difficult to get right. I suppose that at least two of the three versions are wrong. I also note that Richard Jensen has deleted some contemporary material and inserted more historical material. It is clearly a matter of opinion, what should be, or not be, in the article and should be politely discussed on the Talk page, preferably before deleting other people's contributions.

Wrt the link to the government website, which Richard has removed, I imagine that the link was made because the claim that 'Scotland is a country' is contentious. When the UK government describes it as such, the claim is rather stronger. Where is your reference for this claim, Richard? --Martin Baldwin-Edwards 21:45, 4 October 2007 (CDT)

I think it would be more accurate to say "Scotland is a nation" rather than "Scotland is a country", but the distinction is small. See the discussions at The Sage Handbook of Nations and Nationalism (2006) Page 245 online versionRichard Jensen 07:26, 6 October 2007 (CDT)
This is true. The difficulty is with the concept of a "country", which in a redrafting of "Countries of the World" I had tried to address. The problem is that we cannot avoid this, as the UK government insists on calling Scotland and Wales "countries", when the UK is also called a country. I am also very very unhappy about calling Northern Ireland a country, when it is not even a nation! It is a "province" located within another country... I think all these issues need to be addressed in the two articles "Countries of the World" and "United Kingdom", so I will try to do that over the next 10 days or so. --Martin Baldwin-Edwards 08:06, 6 October 2007 (CDT)
very good points--good luck on the changes. Richard Jensen 08:15, 6 October 2007 (CDT)

Speaking as a constable here let me just remind anyone who wants to make substantive changes in text that does not violate clear parameters (e.g. pornography, commercialisation etc.), the deletions must be discussed here first. --Thomas Simmons 00:07, 5 October 2007 (CDT)

NOTICE: Since an editor has weighed in and the Constables have discussed this, the text changes by Richard Jensen (Oct 4 or 5 depending on the time zone) should be reverted and the changes discussed. --Thomas Simmons 17:56, 5 October 2007 (CDT)

I made what I thought were noncontroversial changes. I did not remove any significant facts. I did make a mistake on the question of how the executive is appointed when I wrote "the majority party" when it should be "the majority." I dropped some trivial links that added a footnote that says Scotland is a country. My solution was to start the article with the clear statement "Scotland is a country." (If there is a debate on that point then both sides have to be represented, which was not the case in the text. I unlinked many red links--the article has far too many of these Wikipedia-leftovers. Richard Jensen 18:26, 5 October 2007 (CDT)
Richard: I accept that most of your changes are for the better, but please state clearly in the edit summary exactly what you have done, and where there is possibly any doubt discuss changes on this page. I notice that your edit summaries have been more accurate since my complaint above. Insofar as reversion is concerned, I think we can manage without that. Thank you to the constabulary for being so attentive! The issue of Scotland as a country I will try to address somehow, possibly in the UK article. --Martin Baldwin-Edwards 06:35, 6 October 2007 (CDT)
I'm now replaceing some false myths re Scottish education that were carried over from Wikipedia, with new references to boot. The Sparta myth is totally false, and Anderson has explored the myths of scottish schooling. No CZ author is affected--this stuff was all from Wikipedia and poorly sourced. Richard Jensen 06:49, 6 October 2007 (CDT)

Church of Scotland

I've written a complete article on the Church of Scotland and revised this article accordingly.Richard Jensen 03:06, 7 October 2007 (CDT)

Article from Wikipedia?

If I'm not mistaken, this article was imported from Wikipedia, but I don't see any WP credit. James F. Perry 18:35, 2 February 2008 (CST)

It used to have a WP credit. I'll check it. Derek Harkness 23:02, 2 February 2008 (CST)

Minor changes

I've made what I intended to be minor and uncontroversial changes, small clean-ups, some moving of text to Scottish Parliament, some dropping of more parochial elements.Gareth Leng 04:58, 4 February 2008 (CST)

Home Nation?

"one of the four countries" Should it not be one of 'the home nations'? This is probably a pedantic issue that doesn't really mean anything but what is Scotland regarded as in the Union? A Nation or a region? Denis Cavanagh 07:34, 4 February 2008 (CST)

It's regarded as a country. The Union is a union of countries. The term 'home nations' is not one used commonly outside or sport. While you could use 'nation' some would argue that the word nation refers to the people of the country rather than the geographical entity. The word 'region' has a specific meaning in the structure of the UK and Scotland is not a Region. Scotland used to contain Regions but they have been replaced with Local Areas. Derek Harkness 09:34, 4 February 2008 (CST)


790 islands. Any number of islands, depending on how you define them, but how many inhabited? That would be good information. --Martin Wyatt 21:56, 15 March 2013 (UTC)